The Best Shoulder Holsters: Top 10 Picks for Concealed Carry and Comfort
In a universe where everyone's got an opinion on concealed carry, shoulder holsters are like the rebels of the holster world—defying the skeptics with their timeless charm. Sure, some folks may scoff at them, thinking shoulder carry is deader than disco. But little do they know, in the society of comfort-loving, accessibility-cherishing, and versatility-seeking holster enthusiasts, shoulder holsters are the unsung heroes.
After years of testing these holsters, I'm here to spill the beans. The right shoulder holster isn't just a fashion statement; it's a lifestyle. It's the MacGyver of holsters, adapting to different outfits and body types like a chameleon at a fashion show.
So, dear fans of shoulder holsters, grab your popcorn and get ready for the revelation. In this exposé, I'll be your holster guide, unveiling the top 10 shoulder holsters of 2025, straight from the front lines of my holster adventures. Get ready because shoulder holsters are here to stay, and they're bringing style and practicality back!
Best Overall Shoulder Holster: D901
The D901 stands out for its innovative design, combining the comfort of natural Italian leather with the durability of American Kydex. This hybrid model is equipped with the Roto function and this won't be the last time you hear about this feature on this list. The Roto function allows my Sig Sauer P365 XL to rest in a vertical position, and when I unsnap the forefinger snap, it rotates, making my drawing very ergonomic and easy. It can be custom-made for a variety of handguns and revolvers.
Mine was a perfect fit. The adjustable shoulder harness, double magazine pouch, and leather tie-down straps create a balanced and comfortable carrying experience.
Pros:
- Ergonomic design facilitates the Roto feature for easier draw.
- Adjustable tensioning screw for custom retention.
- Combination of Italian leather and Kydex for durability and comfort.
Cons:
- Available only in black color.
Most Comfortable & Versatile Shoulder Holster: D632 L Carroll
The versatility of the D632 L Carroll is unmatched. It is enhanced and improved version of timeless D602 LR. Designed for guns with lights, lasers, and red dot sights, it is crafted from full-grain premium Italian leather. The adjustable harness that is stitched all around and counterbalance system ensured the comfortable, all-day carry of my Springfield Hellcat. The steel-reinforced thumb break provided a well-balanced ratio between quick access and security. Impressively, it can transform into an OWB holster, adding to its versatility.
Pros:
- Versatile design for shoulder and OWB carry.
- Comfortable fully stitched harness system for balanced wear.
- High-quality leather construction.
- Custom-fit for your handgun, light & even RDS
- Reinforced mouth
- Fast draws
Cons:
- A horizontal position isn't ideal if you have a full-size handgun.
Best Shoulder Holster for Concealed Carry: D631 Broom
The D631 Broom excels in concealed carry with its slim design and single shoulder harness. It is enhanced timeless holster that is was developed on its previous version D601. It provides a vertical position suitable even for larger handguns, along with the famous Roto feature. The mechanism for an ergonomic draw is the same as with the D901 (Hybrid version), and this model made my P365 XL practically disappear. The aroma of full-grain Italian leather construction only adds to its appeal, and the adjustable harness, accommodating up to a 47'' chest circumference, made it a fit for my friend, who can be considered plus-size.
Pros:
- Ideal for concealed carry with a slim profile.
- Roto feature for an ergonomic draw.
- Reinforced mouth keep holster open even when handgun is not holstered.
- Adjustable harness for a custom fit.
- Compatible with red dot sights.
- Harness as well as holster stitched in the areas of highest stress to prolong the lifespan.
- Premium full-grain leather for durability and style.
Cons:
- The absence of a counterbalance makes concealed carry more comfortable and concealable; however, you would need to carry spare magazines somewhere else.
Best Horizontal Shoulder Holster: D128
After testing the D128 with my Glock 19, I must admit it's a healthy mix of speed, security, and god-like craftsmanship. I'm not really into the horizontal position of my handgun while carrying in a shoulder holster, but I am a huge fan of the adjustable retention system.
The soft black underlay and the sight protection kept the holster and my firearm safe and cozy. Plus, its belt tunnel made it excellent for OWB carry too. It's pretty sweet for both larger and smaller-sized handguns.
Pros:
- Adjustable retention for a personalized draw.
- Sight protection to maintain holster and firearm condition.
- Belt tunnel option for alternative carry.
Cons:
- Horizontal carry isn't my cup of tea, but it might be yours.
Best Leather Shoulder Holster: D633 L Sherman
Yet another shoulder holster with roto/folding functionality on this list. I appreciate how the leather shoulder holster D633 L seamlessly blends classic aesthetics with cutting-edge functionality. The vertical roto-holster design, capability to accomodate rail mounted lights and optics not only adds a touch of modernity but also facilitates an ergonomic draw for modern handguns. All its features enhance the overall user experience. What's more, the holster's impressive adaptability, adjustable up to a 47'' chest circumference, ensures a personalized and comfortable fit, making it a standout choice in the realm of concealed carry too.
Pros:
- New Enhanced Timeless leather design.
- Counterbalance for extra magazines
- Compatible with over 3100 handguns, 80 lights and red dot sights
- Durable construction thanks to extra stitching.
- Reinforced mouth for easy reholsterings
- Adjustable harness for various body sizes.
- Roto - ergonomic draw functionality.
Cons:
- Leather requires maintenance to retain its premium look.
Best Kydex Shoulder Holster: D905
The D905, crafted from original American Kydex, stands out as a modern, low-maintenance shoulder holster option. With its horizontal design and adjustable shoulder harness, it proves to be the optimal choice for subcompacts, compacts, and mid-sized revolvers.
What sets this model apart is its exceptional retention and the absence of a thumb break, ensuring a remarkably smooth and fast draw. The fully Kydex horizontal counterbalance for two magazines, equipped with a retention screw, adds to its practicality. Personally, I found the reload experience with this holster to be the most enjoyable among the shoulder holster options on this list.
Pros:
- Low maintenance and durable material.
- Excellent retention
- Smooth & fast draw
- Excellent reloads
Cons:
- Lacks the classic aesthetic of leather shoulder holsters.
Best Shoulder Holster for Women
The D901's adjustable harness, belt straps, and Kydex shell make it an excellent choice for everyone. I tested almost all models on this list with my wife, and the comfortable and customizable harness was easy to set up for her petite body shape too. The ergonomic Roto draw worked very well for her, and my Sig P365 XL basically disappeared under her winter jacket.
Best Budget Shoulder Holster: D808 Mason
The D808 Mason is an affordable nylon shoulder holster that shares the same Roto feature as multiple other shoulder holsters on this list. This means a smooth, safe, and ergonomic draw is available in the form of a cost-attractive, yet highly functional premium nylon shoulder holster. The premium version of nylon means it is reinforced by a layer of leather. This shoulder holster doesn't compromise on any features that the hybrid and leather versions offer; in fact, it even includes more. The integrated plastic sights rail protects your sights, which I found very useful due to the high sights. I tested it with a nylon adjustable harness and a nylon single magazine pouch. The fit for my Sig Sauer P365 XL was perfect, however holster was also a bit more robust than other materials. This makes it a little less effective for concealed carry.
Pros:
- Affordable price point.
- Roto design for an ergonomic draw.
- Durable premium nylon and leather construction.
Cons:
- Nylon material may not appeal to all users.
- Not available for handguns equipped with RDS
- More robust in comparison with leather & hybrid version
Best Light Bearing Shoulder Holster: D131
After 2 weeks long test of this Roto light-bearing shoulder holster with my Sig Sauer P365 XMacro equipped with a red dot and Streamlight TLR7A, I'm impressed by its exceptional craftsmanship and functionality. Crafted from premium Italian full-grain leather, the holster boasts a steel-reinforced forefinger security strap, ensuring a secure fit. Classical Falcos Roto design allows for a vertical rest and a quick, ergonomic draw under an angle. Stability is enhanced by the belt strap slit and plastic loops. The hand-colored lacquered finish and personalized embossing options make it a luxurious yet practical accessory. In a nutshell, this premium holster combines style and functionality, offering a bespoke, long-lasting solution for those who carry their handguns with lights or lasers.
Pros:
- Exceptional craftsmanship and premium Italian leather.
- Roto design for a quick, ergonomic draw.
- Custom-fit for a wide range of handguns and tactical lights.
- Personalization options add a luxurious touch.
Cons:
- Premium quality comes at a higher price point.
- Holster might need time for a break-in.
Q&A
How to Wear a Shoulder Holster?
Wearing a shoulder holster properly involves adjusting the harness and belt straps for maximum comfort and tightness, ensuring that your holster and counterbalance do not move even when in use. The holster should sit snugly under your arm without restricting movement. Ensure that the counterbalance is positioned correctly on the opposite side to distribute the weight evenly.
How to Put on a Shoulder Holster?
Slip your arms through the harness like a backpack, beginning with your weaker side where the holster for your firearm should be. Continue with your stronger side, featuring the counterbalance. If your harness is already adjusted, fasten the entire rig to your belt using the belt straps, and you are good to go.
Is a Shoulder Holster Good for Concealed Carry?
A shoulder holster can be an excellent option for concealed carry, particularly in colder months when jackets or coats are commonly worn. They provide quick access, comfort, and effective concealment, making them a practical choice for many individuals looking to carry their firearms discreetly.
Find more info on the shoulder holster topic here.
Conclusion
So, after diving into the universe of shoulder holsters and uncovering the top contenders of 2025, what's your take on them now? Are you ready to embrace the concealed carry rebellion and give shoulder holsters a spin? Among the reviewed options above, find the one that resonates with you, as your perfect holster should be more than just an accessory. It should be an extension of your style, embodying comfort, reliability, and the readiness to spring into action when a situation needs it.
And for those seeking the epitome of holster luxury, you can never go wrong with a fully personalized high-end custom shoulder holster, because in the world of concealed carry, your holster isn't just a tool; it's your partner for decades, and when it's customized to fit you like a glove, it becomes an indispensable part of your everyday arsenal. So, holster up, be safe, and let your carry game reach new heights!
This article was last updated on October 9th, 2024.
Andrew Miller
7.12.2023
